ADVERTISEMENT

HOUSING

Builders warn road fee spike could devastate Ada County families and drive up home prices

Developers fiercely oppose massive ACHD road fee hike, warning it hurts housing affordability.

Portland weighs new monthly fee for road repairs. (Photo by John Moore/Getty Images)...

Portland weighs new monthly fee for road repairs. (Photo by John Moore/Getty Images)

(Photo by John Moore/Getty Images)

Developers and business leaders are strongly pushing back against the Ada County Highway District’s (ACHD) aggressive proposal to sharply increase impact fees—the costs paid on new construction to fund road projects—warning that the measure will inflate new home prices and harm housing affordability.

The ACHD has identified $1.3 billion tied directly to growth, necessitating the fee hike.

The proposed rates, which could see the impact fee on a new single family home jump by 31% to 98% (averaging near 78% countywide) from the current $3,493 assessment, represent the first “major update” to the funding formula since 2020 and reflect major inflationary leaps in building costs.

Commissioners admit to lack of oversight

The abrupt rise in fees seemed to catch ACHD commissioners off guard, leading to internal admissions of lax oversight over the program.

“I’ve sat here for almost 11 years, and we only talked about these fees once or twice,” Commissioner Kent Goldthorpe told Idaho Statesman. “Maybe I was asleep at the wheel … but I was not aware of the impact of not having these discussions over the past 11 years.”

Commissioner Patricia Nillson echoed the concern promising greater scrutiny going forward.

“I’m going to be bird-dogging it, so that every year we update the [capital improvement plan]. This big jump – I’m not going to tolerate it,” Nillson told Idaho Statesman.

Developers demand responsible policy

The overwhelming majority of the public comment filed before the board meeting came from builders and contractors demanding the ACHD adopt a more responsible constrained approach to policy.

ADVERTISEMENT

Jonathon D. Wardle, president of the long tenured developer Brighton, argued that the proposed increase is unacceptable and inconsistent with past rates.

He suggested the ACHD limit projects, lobby from other revenues, and adjust policy to accept a lower level of service essentially, tolerating more congestion to avoid overburdening new homebuyers.

“The proposed impact fee increase is unacceptable — and inconsistent with the rate of impact fee collections since 2019,” Wardle told Idaho Statesman. “While adjustments should be made, ACHD needs to explore additional options, such as: modifying levels of service, adjusting or eliminating project scopes, lobbying for additional revenues, and indexing impact fee increases.”

Is this legal?

Business owners challenged the legality and scope of the proposal, arguing it places an “undue burden” on new homebuyers by passing costs directly to the consumer.

ADVERTISEMENT

“The proposed increase could price out an estimated thousands of families in Ada County, a devastating impact at a time when affordable housing is already out of reach for many,” according to a form letter signed by multiple business owners.

Clayton Conner, president of the Building Contractor Association of Southwestern Idaho called for legal compliance.

“Our challenge to the ACHD is to more clearly determine what level of development impact fees are fair and appropriate according to law. We contend that ACHD’s currently proposed impact fee changes do not comply with Idaho law and strongly encourage you to re-evaluate how ACHD defines ‘impact fee eligible’ projects, and to which projects those fees are applied,” Conner told Idaho Statesman.

Political division over funding equity

Adding complexity, the ACHD is debating whether to keep a countywide funding rate or split the region into two service areas (East, including Boise, and West, including Meridian, Eagle, and Star). This split would result in significantly higher fees for the rapidly growing West side ($6,918 per home) compared to the East side ($4,610 per home).

ADVERTISEMENT

Boise mayor Lauren McLean backed the split, arguing for “equity” by making areas with greater needs pay more.

Conversely, Meridian Mayor Robert E. Simison supported maintaining the current single district arguing a countywide approach is the “best way to ensure our countywide system delivers the best results” by allowing funds to be used where need is greatest.

The issue remains unresolved, with the ACHD board scheduling a public hearing on the drafts for December 3rd.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Jasneet Gill Content Editor

Jasneet Gill is a content editor and writer for Seattle Red. She is a Washington native, born and raised in the state, and a graduate of the University of Washington with a bachelor's degree in Communications. Her passion for soccer led her to play… Read more

Comments

0 Comments