Republicans try to block proposal to kill 453,000 Barred Owls in Washington, Oregon and California
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s $1.35 billion plan to kill nearly half a million Barred Owls in Washington, Oregon, and California is sparking outrage.
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service is reigniting controversy with a revived plan to kill nearly half a million Barred Owls across Washington, Oregon, and California — a move critics call misguided, expensive, and ethically indefensible. (Photo: Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife)
(Photo: Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife)
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service is reigniting controversy with a revived plan to kill nearly half a million Barred Owls in the Washington, Oregon, and California. Critics say is misguided, expensive, and ethically indefensible.
U.S. Sen. John Kennedy (R-La.) introduced a resolution to block the agency’s “Barred Owl Management Strategy,” which would authorize the extermination of 453,000 owls across Washington, Oregon, and California. Though the Senate declined to advance the resolution, Kennedy and others argue it is a textbook example of federal overreach and ecological micromanagement.
If passed, the resolution would declare the FWS rule to have “no force or effect.” However, an initial motion to proceed with the resolution was rejected in the Senate last Wednesday.
The fiscal and ethical cost of federal intervention
Senator Kennedy has highlighted the staggering financial burden of this FWS initiative, estimating the total cost to taxpayers at $1.35 billion. This includes a $4.5 million contract already awarded in 2024 to kill about 1,500 Barred Owls over four years, which breaks down to an alarming rate of roughly $3,000 per owl, including young chicks, according to The Center Square.
At the core of the issue is the Biden administration’s FWS “Barred Owl Management Strategy,” which purports to “address the threat of the non-native and invasive Barred Owl to native northern and California Spotted Owls.”
The Barred Owl, naturally expanding its historic range, is larger and more aggressive, out-competing the endangered Spotted Owl for nesting sites and food, and even interbreeding.
Challenging the efficacy of annihilation
To “save” the Spotted Owl, the FWS has proposed a “large scale” annihilation of the Barred Owl population. The FWS plans to authorize Tribes, federal, and state agencies, companies, or landowners to carry out the killings under its Migratory Bird Treaty Act permit, while strictly prohibiting public hunting.
Critics argue that this policy is yet another example of failed, decades-long federal intervention in environmental management. This strategy is not new; a similar effort between 2013 and 2016 resulted in the killing of 378 Barred Owls.
Senator Kennedy argues that this latest plan is a continuation of the federal government’s “repeated proclivity to do the dumbest thing possible that won’t work.” The FWS is attempting to manage a naturally occurring ecological phenomenon.
“Barred owls are expanding their habitat because the forests in the east have been cut down. That’s called adaptive range expansion… that happens every single day in our ecosystem,” Kennedy told The Center Square.
Expert skepticism on long-term success
The long-term viability of the Barred Owl killing strategy is highly questioned, even by those familiar with conservation.
A former FWS biologist was cited as saying that trying “to control Barred Owls across a large region would be incredibly expensive, and you’d have to keep doing it forever because if you ever stopped, they would begin to come back into these areas.”
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
0 Comments