ADVERTISEMENT

CULTURE

Supreme Court shift gives Idaho green light to reinstate transgender birth certificate ban

Idaho Attorney General Raúl Labrador is asking a federal court to lift a 2018 injunction blocking enforcement of the state’s ban on changing birth certificate sex markers, citing new Supreme Court rulings that bolster states’ rights on gender and medical issues.

they/them buttons...

Several ballot measures across the country protecting girls' sports passed. (Photo: Jason Rantz/Seattle Red)

(Photo: Jason Rantz/Seattle Red)

Idaho Attorney General Raúl Labrador is attempting to reinstitute the state’s ban on transgender people from changing their gender on their birth certificate, per the Idaho Statesmen.

State law prohibits such changes unless a mistake had been made in recording someone’s sex at birth. But in 2018, U.S. District Court Judge Candy Dale ruled that “automatically and categorically” preventing a transgender person from changing their sex on their birth certificate is unconstitutional. The ban has been put on ice ever since that injunction.

“For seven years, Idaho has been blocked from enforcing a law requiring birth certificates to reflect biological facts recorded at birth… But recent Supreme Court decisions have changed the legal landscape, and now we’re asking that court to lift the block and let Idaho enforce our law,” Labrador said in a press release.

New precedent clears the way

Labrador is referring to two Supreme Court cases decided earlier this year—Trump v. CASA and United States v. Skrmetti.

At the crux of CASA was the notion of birthright citizenship, and while the court steered away from ruling on that issue it did limit lower courts’ ability to issue nationwide injunctions.

That is, an injunction can only be placed on the parties involved in a case. They cannot be used to strike down policies a judge doesn’t like writ large.

In Skrmetti, the court ruled that a Tennessee law banning transgender procedures on minors was constitutional. The majority determined the ban is based on age and medical use and thus was not tantamount to sex-based discrimination.

“SB1 classifies on the basis of age,” Chief Justice John Roberts wrote in the majority opinion.

“Healthcare providers may administer certain medical treatments to individuals ages 18 and older but not to minors. Second, SB1 classifies on the basis of medical use. Healthcare providers may administer puberty blockers or hormones to minors to treat certain conditions but not to treat gender dysphoria, gender identity disorder, or gender incongruence.”

Next steps

These two cases would seem to render the 2018 injunction placed on Idaho’s law null and void.

If the injunction is lifted, a 2020 Idaho law that says someone’s sex on their birth certificate can only be challenged in court on the basis of “fraud, duress, or material mistake of fact” would also go into effect.

The state legislature updated the law last year to “provide clear procedures for correcting genuine errors on birth certificates,” according to Labrador’s spokesperson Damon Sidur. Labrador has filed this case with the U.S. District Court in Idaho.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jackson Meyer Producer, The Jason Rantz Show

Born and raised in Issaquah, Jackson is a lifelong Washingtonian. He is an avid sports fan, particularly of baseball, which he played at the varsity level in High School. He worked at the Seattle-based conservative think tank Discovery Institute for… Read more

Comments

0 Comments