ADVERTISEMENT

WASHINGTON STATE

City of Everett illegally withheld union dues for 14 pay periods despite clear opt-out: employee

Everett employee appeals PERC ruling over unauthorized union dues, citing First Amendment violations under Janus.

An employee in Everett is taking the city to court. (Photo: National Right to Work)...

An employee in Everett is taking the city to court. (Photo: National Right to Work)

(Photo: National Right to Work)

Xenia Davidsen, an employee of the City of Everett, is challenging a ruling by the Washington State Public Employment Relations Commission (PERC) that let union officials and city bureaucrats off the hook for illegally deducting union dues from her paycheck despite her clear request to stop.

Davidsen, represented by attorneys from the National Right to Work Foundation, argues that both the City of Everett and the American Federation of State County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME) violated her First Amendment rights under the landmark Janus v. AFSCME Supreme Court decision. That ruling affirmed that public employees cannot be forced to financially support a union they do not wish to join unless they voluntarily waive those rights.

The continued unauthorized deductions

According to Davidsen’s appeal, she revoked her dues authorization in June 2024. Union officials acknowledged her request and told the city to stop the deductions. Yet over the course of 14 separate pay periods, the city continued to take money from her paycheck and AFSCME gladly accepted it.

The appeal alleges that Everett officials failed to monitor email addresses designated for union communications, allowing the unauthorized deductions to continue. AFSCME accepted the funds without question even though they knew the money was improperly taken.

“On none of those instances did the Union stop to question why it was accepting dues that it knew were unauthorized to it,” Davidsen’s brief says.

Despite this, the PERC hearing examiners found no violation of Washington labor law.

Challenge to PERC’s reasoning and timeliness

Davidsen also disputed the Examiner’s logic in clearing the city of responsibility. Her attorney argues that the Examiner’s reasoning effectively allows the city to “indefinitely deduct dues that it has constructive notice it must put a stop to.”

ADVERTISEMENT

The appeal further challenges the Examiner’s decision to dismiss the complaint as untimely under the six month statute of limitations.

Davidsen’s legal team contends that each unauthorized deduction should count as a separate violation rather than treating the initial failure to act as the only event at issue.

“AFSCME union officials believe they should be able to hold onto the hard earned money of dissenting employees like Ms. Davidsen simply because they and City of Everett officials refuse to correct their own misdeeds,” commented National Right to Work Foundation President Mark Mix. “Under Janus, union bosses must now convince public sector workers to voluntarily support their agenda, and are not entitled to take or keep any money they know was seized without that voluntarism,” he concluded.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Jasneet Gill Content Editor

Jasneet Gill is a content editor and writer for Seattle Red. She is a Washington native, born and raised in the state, and a graduate of the University of Washington with a bachelor's degree in Communications. Her passion for soccer led her to play… Read more

Comments

1 Comments

P
Pablo Abo 1 year ago

the PERC hearing examiners found no violation of Washington labor law.
Wonder if those hearing examiners are also union members... That would be an obvious conflict of interest and highly unethical.