Snohomish firefighters asks for help as Ninth Circuit upholds COVID-19 vaccine suspension
Firefighters suspended over COVID mandates seek Ninth Circuit rehearing backed by First Liberty over religious rights dispute.
Eight Snohomish Firefighters were put on leave for refusing to accept a COVID-vaccine leading to a religious accomodation trial. (Photo: Snohomish Fire and Rescue)
(Photo: Snohomish Fire and Rescue)
A group of eight Snohomish Regional Fire & Rescue firefighters disciplined for refusing the COVID-19 vaccine on religious grounds are pressing for a rehearing before the full Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. Their legal team, joined by the prominent religious liberty firm First Liberty Institute, argues the panel that upheld their suspension ignored key evidence and misapplied a landmark Supreme Court decision protecting religious employees.
The case, Petersen v. Snohomish Regional Fire & Rescue, centers on firefighters who were placed on unpaid leave in 2021 after declining COVID vaccination. They requested religious accommodations that would have allowed them to continue working under existing safety protocols, including masks, testing, and distancing, that had already been in use for nearly two years without incident.
Attorney Jennifer W. Kennedy, representing the firefighters, filed the petition for rehearing en banc, asserting the panel “overstepped its role at summary judgment” by weighing evidence that should have been left to a jury. Kennedy argued that the appellate panel failed to apply the Supreme Court’s 2023 ruling in Groff v. DeJoy, which raised the standard for what qualifies as an “undue hardship” for employers when denying religious accommodations.
The firefighters also point to inconsistencies in the department’s own behavior.
After placing them on unpaid leave in October 2021, Snohomish Fire reinstated the same employees to their duties just six months later—while the pandemic and state vaccine mandates remained in effect. Their legal team argues that the department’s decision to return them to duty under the same protocols undermines its claim that accommodations would have been impossible earlier.
What comes next?
First Liberty Institute—a Texas-based religious liberty law firm best known for its victory in Groff v. DeJoy—filed an amicus brief urging the full Ninth Circuit to rehear the case. First Liberty argues that the panel “improperly assumed the role of the jury” and ignored genuine factual disputes, including whether Snohomish Fire could have reasonably accommodated the firefighters without undue hardship.
If the Ninth Circuit grants the request for en banc review, the case could help determine how broadly Groff v. DeJoy applies in the wake of widespread COVID-era mandates—and how far employers must go to accommodate workers’ religious beliefs before claiming undue hardship.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
1 Comments
The 9th circuit is just a bunch of leftist hacks. Just like Meteorologists, they get to keep their jobs despite being wrong 99% of the time.