Travis Couture: The Obamacare lie is finally collapsing — and Democrats want you to pay for it again
Obamacare was never about affordability—it was about government control.
State Rep. Travis Couture says you've been sold a false promise on affordable healthcare. (Getty Images)
(Getty Images)
Back in 2013, which feels like a lifetime ago, I was one of the voices in Washington state politics warning against expanding Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act. The sales pitch from D.C. was irresistible: billions in “free” federal money to cover more people. What first started off with the Feds covering 100% slowly dwindled down back to reality. I said then it wasn’t free, that the bill would come due, and now we’re all paying it because the gravy train is over.
Democrats will say, “But the ACA helped millions!” Yet if you measure success by health outcomes, affordability, and sustainability instead of sheer enrollment, the story changes. We didn’t solve the cost crisis, we nationalized it. We didn’t make care more accessible, we made paperwork universal.
The ACA was never truly about affordability or care, it was about control. Democrats sold it as a moral crusade and hitched their entire wagon to one clever talking point: pre-existing conditions. That line was politically untouchable. Who would oppose the sick getting coverage? But forcing insurers to take everyone at nearly the same rate destroyed the math of insurance itself. It turned shared risk into guaranteed loss, guaranteeing endless premium hikes and taxpayer bailouts.
Affordable Care Act was never going to be affordable
Even one of the ACA’s own designers, Jonathan Gruber, later admitted the law was written in a “tortured” way to hide its true costs and that it relied on, in his words, “the stupidity of the American voter” to pass. He wasn’t confessing brilliance, he was confessing political manipulation. Transparency would have doomed it and confusion inevitably made it possible.
Democrats like to say the private market was broken before the ACA. Broken for whom? For millions who could still find affordable plans tailored to their needs? For small businesses that weren’t drowning in compliance? The system wasn’t perfect and no one pretends it was, but it was at least functional. What came next was not reform but redesign from the top down, with D.C. and big insurance deciding what “choice” looked like.
The individual mandate was their enforcement arm. For the first time in American history, citizens were fined simply for existing without government-approved coverage. Working families who couldn’t afford ACA premiums were punished for being priced out and Democrats framed that coercion as “shared responsibility.” I called it economic punishment for the middle class.
Then came the subsidies, Washington’s favorite illusion.
They didn’t make insurance cheaper, they merely hid (and shifted) the price tag. When costs ballooned, Democrats claimed victory because the pain was shifted to taxpayers. And the biggest prize of all, Medicaid expansion, moved millions of able-bodied adults from private plans into a government program never designed for them. Expansion didn’t fix healthcare, it swelled dependency, not to mention our deficits.
The myth of ACA saving lives
Supporters still insist expansion “saved lives.” Yet, state budgets tell another story: crowded classrooms, underfunded law enforcement, and shrinking infrastructure dollars, all traded for a program whose outcomes remain statistically flat. If the goal was better health, we failed. What did succeed is permanent reliance, and on that front, mission accomplished for Democrats.
Health exchanges were supposed to unleash competition, instead the opposite happened and they crushed it. In many areas your “choice” today is between two mega insurers selling nearly identical plans at identical prices. That’s not a free market. That’s a government blessed cartel. Before the ACA, hundreds of regional insurers competed for business. After it, only the biggest corporations could survive the regulatory gauntlet. Democrats call that “choice.” I call it corporate fascism where big government writes the rules that guarantee big business profits while families foot the bill.
I felt it personally at the time. Years ago I lost my excellent health plan because it was labeled a “Cadillac plan.” I paid more for less care. It felt like punishment for doing things the right way, earning good coverage through hard work instead of depending on government programs.
The ACA walls are cracking again
In 2025 the walls are cracking again. The temporary subsidies President Biden and Democrats added in 2021 to “save” Obamacare expire at the end of 2025. When they do, millions will see what this system actually costs without another trillion dollar Band-Aid. And rather than admit the policy failed, Democrats will demand we make those subsidies permanent, another step toward government-run socialized medicine.
They’ll shout, “You just want to take people’s coverage away!” No, we want to give people real coverage back. Plans people can afford, that doctors actually accept, and that don’t depend on bureaucrats in D.C. to survive. Having a plastic insurance card isn’t the same as having access to care. It’s time we stopped confusing bureaucracy with progress.
And they’ll ask again, “Where’s the Republican plan?” Here it is: freedom, transparency, competition. Let prices mean something again. Let doctors and patients make decisions instead of lobbyists and legislators. You don’t fix what 2,000 pages of regulation broke by writing 2,000 more. You fix it by getting government out of the exam room and by embracing the efficiency and innovation of the free market.
ACA was pushed deceptively and we’re paying the price
Even Gruber’s candid remarks years ago confirmed what many of us said from day one: The ACA was built on deception, sustained by subsidies, and structured to fail unless government took more control. That’s not compassion, it’s central planning with a hug and a smiley face.
We could have reformed healthcare honestly, transparently, and locally. Instead, we engineered dependency, destroyed competition, and called it mercy. And just as some of us warned twelve years ago, the financial, moral, and political costs have finally come due. Now we are asked to bail out this failed policy once again, with our government being held hostage until we do so.
State Representative Travis Couture, R-Allyn, is the Assistant Minority Floor Leader, the ranking minority member of the House Appropriations Committee, and a member of the House Education Committee.






Comments
1 Comments
Still, your "plan" offers no promises regarding pre-existing conditions and as you observe, there aren't enough players for competition. Healthcare is not immigration, it's not lax law enforcement and it's not homelessness. You'll have difficulty convincing many Red citizens that they will ne better off under the old system, where there were no guarantees.