ADVERTISEMENT

SEATTLE RED OPINION

Rantz: Seattle mayoral frontrunner wants to force you to subsidize biased media outlets

Seattle mayoral frontrunner Katie Wilson wants taxpayers to fund her “News Notes” plan, forcing residents to subsidize local media outlets—even ones they oppose.

Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson speaks during the 2025 campaign, which later drew a formal penalty after...

Seattle is still trying to recover $13.1 million it overpaid to about 900 police officers in June. (Photo: Frank Lenzi/KIRO Newsradio)

(Photo: Frank Lenzi/KIRO Newsradio)

Seattle mayoral frontrunner Katie Wilson wants to force taxpayers to subsidize media outlets we may fundamentally oppose. It’s a well-intentioned, but deeply flawed and entirely too undefined idea.

Under her plan, dubbed “News Notes,” every Seattle resident would be given $100 in taxpayer-funded vouchers to hand out to “local news outlets of their choice.” It sounds like a democracy voucher for journalism. In reality, it’s a socialist scheme dressed up as civic innovation—and it’s a direct threat to free speech.

In a recent interview on the Mostly Economics podcast, Wilson framed her proposal as a response to what she calls the “crisis in the journalism industry.” She lamented that “we do not have a sustainable financial model for supporting local news outlets” and suggested that taxpayers pick up the tab through “a small property tax levy, a capital gains tax, or a digital ad tax.” On The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM, she admitted that it’s not necessarily a fully developed plan and that it’s intended to help smaller media outlets, like websites, and possibly radio.

But in practice, this would allow the government to raid your wallet to prop up the same biased outlets that demonize conservatives. Even worse, she acknowledges the biggest challenge is defining who qualifies as “journalism.” She admitted, “There’s a real challenge there of how are you defining those eligibility criteria so that you are as much as possible being fair.”

ADVERTISEMENT

That’s bureaucratic doublespeak for government deciding what counts as “legitimate news.” Who makes that call? A left-wing city hall that already treats conservative outlets as “bad actors”?

This isn’t about saving independent journalism

Wilson insists this is about saving “independent journalism.” I believe her.

But she’s ignoring the role of the marketplace in determining what outlets get supported. By creating a government-run subsidy system, she introduces the exact opposite of independent journalism: government control of the press. The minute taxpayer dollars are tied to journalism, politicians and bureaucrats inevitably meddle in defining who gets paid and who gets blacklisted.

Wilson pretends her program sidesteps this by letting “individual residents” decide. But those residents can only choose from a list of “approved” outlets. And who approves the list? The very politicians who stand to gain from friendly coverage.

ADVERTISEMENT

Any resident could choose to support independent media today if they chose. After years of shoddy coverage, The Stranger fell into hard economic times. They asked for donations and received them. Many local outlets do the same now. Wilson dismissed the idea of just giving tax cuts to Seattle residents who would then choose how to spend that money, which could include donating to a local media outlet or spending it in a local shop, which is just as advantageous to the community.

A Trojan Horse for partisan media?

Wilson revealed her ideological motivation in the podcast, praising “advocacy journalism” outlets like The Urbanist, Publicola, and the South Seattle Emerald. These are activist sites pushing the same progressive policies that wrecked Seattle in the first place.

Under “News Notes,” they would rake in taxpayer cash while dissenting voices are either shut out or vilified as “misinformation.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Wilson tweeted after Cascade PBS cut its newsroom: “Seattle needs a thriving local news ecosystem. That’s why I’ve proposed ‘News Notes’.” Would she make the same post about Seattle Red or any local conservative outlet? I don’t think so. And it explains what this is all about: she wants to use taxpayer dollars to fund left-wing sources of news that benefit her cause.

Why should you pay for this?

The reality is, taxpayers shouldn’t be forced to bankroll her preferred media ecosystem. Nor should you be forced to fund my preferred media outlet. A progressive taxpayer would be right to complain of taxpayer dollars forcibly used to bankroll Seattle Red, the same way a conservative would be livid if their taxes funded The Stranger.

If people want to support Cascade PBS, The Urbanist, or the South Seattle Emerald, they are free to donate or support those outlets’ sponsors. That’s what real free speech looks like: voluntary choice, not coerced subsidies.

ADVERTISEMENT

The market has already spoken. Outlets survive if they deliver value to readers, listeners, or viewers. Those that fail, usually fail for a good reason. Propping them up with government money isn’t civic engagement—it’s socialism disguised as “news vouchers.” Seattle doesn’t need another tax. It doesn’t need another socialist scheme, either.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

9 Comments

Y
Yea Right 1 year ago

Typical. Seattle is way over budgeted so let’s establish a new give away program.

K
Karl Johnson 1 year ago

Trump is the least of Seattle’s problems nor is he trying to force people to subsidize speech like Katie Wilson while funneling money at the same time to people who vote for her and support her.

Trump is just an excuse for you to deflect.

S
Shawn m 1 year ago

Evidently, Seattle's failing is too big to fail?