Rantz: How a Seattle Times columnist used an assassination and memorial to smear Charlie Kirk
Seattle Times columnist Naomi Ishisaka intentionally leaves out context of Charlie Kirk quotes to paint him as a racist.
UW professor Cliff Mass says a Seattle Times Climate Lab story on Skagit River flooding ignored federal flow data. (Photo: Linda Thomas, KIRO Newsradio)
(Photo: Linda Thomas, KIRO Newsradio)
The Seattle Times‘ least credible columnist, Naomi Ishisaka, just did what contributed to getting Karen Attiah fired from the Washington Post. But don’t hold your breath for accountability—especially from a publication like the Seattle Times.
In her latest column, Ishisaka didn’t just write a eulogy for journalistic standards; she orchestrated a hit piece on Charlie Kirk cloaked in faux concern for free speech. She accuses others of spreading misinformation while shamelessly misrepresenting Kirk’s own words, ripping them out of context to paint him as a bigot, a misogynist, and a danger to society. This is a tactic pulled straight from Karen Attiah’s now-infamous playbook—the same one that got Attiah shown the door at the Washington Post after she falsely claimed Kirk made a sweeping declaration that all black women lacked the intelligence to be taken seriously. It was a lie when Attiah made the claim. It remained a vicious lie when Ishisaka uttered the same claim, though she did so days after the smear ended Attiah’s sad Washington Post career.
Ishisaka wrote:
But in the days following the assassination, it became no longer enough to say you condemn the killing. No, you also had to praise and valorize Kirk, a man who was outspoken on his opinions about Black people, immigrants, transgender people and others.
For example, last year, Kirk said on his show, “If I see a Black pilot, I’m going to be like, ‘boy, I hope he’s qualified.’” About Michelle Obama, Joy Reid, Ketanji Brown Jackson and other Black women, he said in 2023, “You do not have the brain processing power to otherwise be taken really seriously. You had to go steal a white person’s slot to go be taken somewhat seriously.”
There’s a reason Ishisaka, and other Kirk haters, take him out of context. Presenting his argument would condemn the very policies they endorse. Attiah omitted that context and got burned for it. And now Ishisaka does the same thing, except she does it with even more calculated dishonesty.
Context matters, which is why Ishisaka removed it
In both instances, Charlie Kirk was criticizing the Left’s push around so-called “DEI hires,” where Democrats push racial quotas even at the expense of the most qualified.
The point—whether you agree with it or not—was that any hiring done based on race rather than merit creates doubt, even for those who are fully qualified. It’s a criticism of equity policies, not of black pilots. But Ishisaka cuts out the argument entirely and serves you the most damaging, viral soundbite she can muster.
According to the transcript of his show, Kirk said: “You wanna go thought crime? I’m sorry. If I see a Black pilot, I’m gonna be like, ‘Boy, I hope he’s qualified.’ That’s not an immediate … that’s not who I am. That’s not what I believe. I want to be as blunt as possible because now I’m connecting two dots. Wait a second, this CEO just said that he’s forcing that a white qualified guy is not gonna get the job. So I see this guy, he might be a nice person and I say, ‘Boy, I hope he’s not a Harvard-style affirmative-action student that … landed half of his flight-simulator trials.’ It also … creates unhealthy thinking patterns. I don’t wanna think that way. And no one should, right?”
Fact check: altered
Ishiaka then brings up Kirk’s quote about Michelle Obama and others: “You do not have the brain processing power to otherwise be taken really seriously. You had to go steal a white person’s slot.” Ishisaka presents this as a blanket statement about black women. And, again, the quote is intentionally taken out of context. Yahoo! News pointed out that it’s an altered quote.
Kirk’s point was that these individuals were elevated to positions of power through racial preferences, not merit. And he was quoting them.
Former Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee said, “I rise today as a clear recipient of affirmative action, particularly in higher education.” Similarly, Joy Reid said, “I got into Harvard because of affirmative action” and “Yes, I am DEI. Yes, I only got in to colleges on affirmative action.”
Here’s the full context from a transcript of the show:
If we would have said three weeks ago […] that Joy Reid and Michelle Obama and Sheila Jackson Lee and Ketanji Brown Jackson were affirmative-action picks, we would have been called racist. But now they’re comin’ out and they’re saying it for us! They’re comin’ out and they’re saying, ‘I’m only here because of affirmative action.’
Yeah, we know. You do not have the brain processing power to otherwise be taken really seriously. You had to go steal a white person’s slot to go be taken somewhat seriously.
You can choose to dislike the argument he made. But the context is clear: he was talking about the effects of affirmative action on how people perceive the beneficiaries of the left-wing policy. Ishisaka knows this. But she buries the context on purpose because it undermines her narrative.
Here’s why Ishiaka is criticizing Kirk
She knowingly takes him out of context to defend people getting dragged for so disgustingly smearing him after his assassination and yet, Ishisaka has the gall to complain about the “silencing” of people. She bemoans that it’s “no longer enough to say you condemn the killing,” but that people are also expected not to slander the dead with decades-old, context-stripped quotes.
Imagine that.
She mourns Karen Attiah’s firing like it was a speech casualty. But both women did the same thing: they edited their opponent’s views down to the ugliest version possible, then used that cartoon to justify ideological rage. That’s not journalism. It’s propaganda.
The truth is, Ishisaka wasn’t writing about Charlie Kirk to inform. She was writing to settle scores. Kirk’s popularity and very existence offended her, so his death became an opportunity. But unlike Attiah, Ishisaka won’t be fired. Not in Seattle. She works at a paper where left-wing orthodoxy is the job description. Misquoting conservatives isn’t a bug—it’s a feature. And, in fairness, if the Seattle Times fired reporters or columnists for bad faith articles, they wouldn’t have much of a staff.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
1 Comments
Naomi Ishisaka had a piece a while back that essentially said it's okay and healthy to be overweight, flying in the face of science, as part of a greater push back against "fat shaming" whatever that is. Since that time I saw where 3 different "fat influencers" died in their 40s because they ignored the realities of obesity being bad for your health. Yes that's right folks, when The Seattle Times isn't covering up horrific cases of child abuse to protect local politicians, they're offering up advice that kills people.
It can't be overstated how detrimental The Seattle Times has been to the city of Seattle. Naomi Ishisaka has absolutely no business being a columnist when she continually serves up easily refutable and destructive lies.