ADVERTISEMENT

CULTURE

Oregon Supreme Court to rule on censorship in vaping packaging case

Oregon Supreme Court will hear case challenging state law that bans flavor names and slang on vape packaging. Goldwater Institute says law violates free speech rights for legal businesses.

Different flavors for vaping pipes, or electronic cigarettes, are viewed for sale at the newly open...

Different flavors for vaping pipes, or electronic cigarettes, are viewed for sale at the newly opened Henley Vaporium, on December 19, 2013 in New York City. The New York City Council on Thursday will vote on a bill that would add electronic cigarettes to the city's strict smoking ban. If the Mayor Bloomberg backed ban is approved, the city would give businesses and restaurants a year to put up signs indicating there is no smoking or vaping allowed. The Henley Vaporium features a smoking bar and a coffee bar where tea and snacks are served in a relaxed environment. (Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images)

(Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images)

The Oregon Supreme Court is preparing to hear a case that could reshape commercial speech protections in the state, after a district law punished lawful small‐business owners by censoring how they describe vape products.

The case, brought by the Goldwater Institute on behalf of vape shop owner Paul Bates, challenges a state law that silences businesses under vague “attractive to minors” rules imposed by the Oregon Health Authority (OHA). Bates owns a legally licensed vaping business. Nothing he sells is illegal. Yet current Oregon law bans certain words and flavor descriptions from appearing on packaging—mere descriptors like “strawberry,” “apple,” “tart,” “tangy,” or even slang such as “cool,” “lit,” and “poppin’,” potentially deemed “attractive to minors.”

The law forces Bates and similar businesses to obscure or remove truthfully descriptive information from their labels, undermining both regulatory clarity and consumer rights, he argues.

Law did nothing to stop minors from using vapes

According to Goldwater Institute staff attorney John Thorpe, this kind of speech restriction does nothing to stop minors from obtaining these products—they are already prohibited by law from purchasing them, and from entering stores that sell them. The law, however, harms business owners who want to truthfully market legal products, and consumers who rely on accurate product labeling.

After Goldwater filed a lawsuit, the Oregon Court of Appeals struck down the law, declaring it violates the Oregon Constitution’s guarantee of free speech. The appeals court held that the state cannot ban lawful businesses from truthfully describing their products.

Now the Oregon Supreme Court will have its say.

ADVERTISEMENT

How will Oregon State Supreme Court decide?

On October 8, the case is scheduled for oral arguments before the state’s highest court. Goldwater attorneys are confident. They argue precedent supports that commercial speech—even when regulated—cannot be censored in such sweeping, vague ways.

For conservative legal watchers, the case is a critical test of where the line lies between protecting minors (or appearing to), and trampling constitutional speech rights for business owners. If the Supreme Court upholds the higher court decision, it would reinforce that government cannot suppress truthful speech simply because some find it “attractive.”

But if the law is reinstated, small businesses in Oregon—and potentially elsewhere—will face an uncertain regulatory burden, forced to guess which flavor names or marketing terms might be banned next.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

0 Comments