ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ

Cliff Mass shreds Seattle Times, NYT over ‘blatantly false’ megafire claims

University of Washington atmospheric scientist Cliff Mass accuses the New York Times and Seattle Times of publishing false claims about megafire risks in Western Washington.

University of Washington atmospheric sciences professor Cliff Mass is calling out both the New York Times and the Seattle Times for what he calls a “blatantly false” narrative about the future risk of megafires in Western Washington.

“How do I know the writer got it wrong? Because for the past two years, I have researched this very issue and just published a paper on this topic in the peer-reviewed literature (here). I have read every paper and report on this issue,” he wrote.

According to Mass, the articles in question claim that human‑induced climate change will increase the frequency of massive, region‑devastating wildfires. They’re defined as those burning hundreds of thousands of acres. But Mass pushes back hard, pointing out that since 1900, only one such event, the Yacolt Fire of 1902, which scorched 238,000 acres just north of the Columbia River, meets that definition.

Facts, not opinions

Mass also stresses that there has been no uptick in the number or scale of large-scale fires in Western Washington over the past fifty years—even as the planet has warmed. The reason? Western Washington’s lush, damp environment simply isn’t conducive to megafires, unless you have strong, sustained easterly winds.

Those winds, Mass warns, are actually diminished under climate change scenarios. This, he argues, isn’t merely a difference of opinion — it’s a case of sloppy journalism. By ignoring the historical record and the underlying meteorology, the NYT and Seattle Times risk misinforming the public, and worse, derailing effective policy decisions.

ADVERTISEMENT

Cliff Mass’s critique is more than academic nitpicking. It underscores the importance of nuance, historical context, and meteorological expertise when reporting on climate-related threats. If the reporting doesn’t withstand the scrutiny of local experts, it should not stand.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on stg-seattleredcom-staging.kinsta.cloud.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

2 Comments

B
Barry Champlain 1 year ago

But if you applied the same nuance to your political arguments and culture war stoking that Mass applies to his field, you wouldn't get as many clicks.

A
Andre Marcille 1 year ago

The media and large percentage of the population here, it would seem, aren't interested in facts, as demonstrated by one of the other commentators here. They want to go with their feels and damn the facts. They want to use climate change as a lever to do the things they want to do, and can't be bothered with a silly little thing like facts. It's only narrative that matters. NYT and ST are glaring examples of that.